2012 American Idol Thread! - Page 5 - The DVC Boards at MouseOwners.com - the place to talk DVC and Walt Disney World

minniekissedme · 03-29-2012, 10:41 PM

Forgot we had this thread! Last night they were all good, very good, or just plain awesome.

Heejun made up for lackluster performances with his selection last night. Elise doing Zepplin last night was awesome. She tore it up!

I'm with John...I'm not a Deandre fan and I think Holly's number may be up tonight.

jrbdad · 03-30-2012, 01:28 AM

How did we forget about Hee-Jun? I thought he did good last night, but he wasn't going to be on much longer anyway. He did provide some really good comic relief. Had hoped he'd last another week or two. Really thought Skylar was better than Deandre

jrbdad · 04-05-2012, 06:58 PM

Well? Anyone still watching?

Some are really improving and putting together great performances - others - meh.

Bottom three IMHO: Deandre, Hollie, Elise

Brian5581 · 04-05-2012, 07:01 PM

Got to get caught up this weekend. Didn't watch last week's results show yet, then will have last night's show and of course tonight's results. Based solely on who's remaining though, I'd have to say your prediction is likely correct, John.

jrbdad · 04-05-2012, 07:06 PM

Honestly, it was probably Deandre's best performance yet - a major improvement over prior weeks. I'm amazed at Hollie's voice - she is good. Love Elise, but she just didn't work that song the way she could have.

Joshua & Jessica appear to be the front runners. Colton, Phillip, and Skylar were good too though.

tomandrobin · 04-05-2012, 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jrbdad

Honestly, it was probably Deandre's best performance yet - a major improvement over prior weeks. I'm amazed at Hollie's voice - she is good. Love Elise, but she just didn't work that song the way she could have.

Joshua & Jessica appear to be the front runners. Colton, Phillip, and Skylar were good too though.

We are hoping that tonight is Deandre's last night.

Elise did not do well.....she'll probably go home. She did great before, and was bottom three, so I think she is done.

Skylar knocked it out of the park last night. She is not our favorite, but she did very well.....surprised us both.

Presley · 04-05-2012, 08:29 PM

I don't watch every week, but did watch last night. Joshua is always my favorite by a mile. I think Jessica's voice is incredible, but I don't see it as being unique compared to what is already in the mainstream.

Skylar was great last night. When she was chosen for the final 24, I didn't see the attraction. Finally, last night, I could see what the judges apparently saw weeks ago.

DeAndre - he wins the cute kid with the nice hair award. He is very talented, but I just can't stand the sound of the high range. I felt the same way about Fantasia years ago. I couldn't stand the sound of her voice, but did appreciate that she had talent.

John n Karen · 04-06-2012, 03:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jrbdad

Well? Anyone still watching?

Some are really improving and putting together great performances - others - meh.

Bottom three IMHO: Deandre, Hollie, Elise

Great call, John

Quote:

Originally Posted by tomandrobin

We are hoping that tonight is Deandre's last night.

Same here. Finally, we can start enjoying the performances without having to skip through his wailing.

jrbdad · 04-19-2012, 01:43 PM

Hmmmm...not many "wow" moments from last night. Judges have become meaningless - I mean what purpose do the serve? Little if any criticism or even feedback on who should be in the bottom. And, believe me, I enjoy looking at J-Lo as much as any guy - but what the heck was she wearing? Looked like something off Star Trek.

Bottom three is getting tough because it has become such a "popularity" contest. My bottom three were: Hollie, Colton, and Elise. I'm doubting that America will see it that way. I think Elise goes home - which is a shame, I enjoy her singing - but the judges did get their comments right on her she needs to cut loose like she did with the Zepplin song.

Thought Phillip and Joshua did really well. Skylar continues to surprise me - she is probably the most improved and may be the best "performer."

Thought the idea of a try at a "soul" song was good - but the performances didn't seem very good. Oh well.

minniekissedme · 04-19-2012, 02:09 PM

Don't two have to go tonight?

Colton sure did himself no favors with his lame attempt at EWF. The audience was so underwhelmed and had no clue what he performed. If he goes, which I think could be possible, Phillip Phillips could come out the winner. I thought he was super last night.

I'm getting perturbed with Joshua and his "screaming" every song. I'd like him to just sing a bit more...

03-29-2012, 10:41 PM	#41
minniekissedme Add-on Aficionado Join Date: May 2008 Location: In my car with three kids. Posts: 6,665	Forgot we had this thread! Last night they were all good, very good, or just plain awesome. Heejun made up for lackluster performances with his selection last night. Elise doing Zepplin last night was awesome. She tore it up! I'm with John...I'm not a Deandre fan and I think Holly's number may be up tonight. __________________ Are you MOD? aka MouseOwnersDad?? Click here to join! MKM Maulers 2012-13 Champion of the MODly Men of the World Fantasy Football League

03-30-2012, 01:28 AM	#42
jrbdad Add-on Aficionado Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: North Louisiana Posts: 8,286	How did we forget about Hee-Jun? I thought he did good last night, but he wasn't going to be on much longer anyway. He did provide some really good comic relief. Had hoped he'd last another week or two. Really thought Skylar was better than Deandre __________________ *John*

04-05-2012, 06:58 PM	#43
jrbdad Add-on Aficionado Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: North Louisiana Posts: 8,286	Well? Anyone still watching? Some are really improving and putting together great performances - others - meh. Bottom three IMHO: Deandre, Hollie, Elise __________________ *John*

04-05-2012, 07:06 PM	#45
jrbdad Add-on Aficionado Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: North Louisiana Posts: 8,286	Honestly, it was probably Deandre's best performance yet - a major improvement over prior weeks. I'm amazed at Hollie's voice - she is good. Love Elise, but she just didn't work that song the way she could have. Joshua & Jessica appear to be the front runners. Colton, Phillip, and Skylar were good too though. __________________ *John*

04-19-2012, 01:43 PM	#49
jrbdad Add-on Aficionado Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: North Louisiana Posts: 8,286	Hmmmm...not many "wow" moments from last night. Judges have become meaningless - I mean what purpose do the serve? Little if any criticism or even feedback on who should be in the bottom. And, believe me, I enjoy looking at J-Lo as much as any guy - but what the heck was she wearing? Looked like something off Star Trek. Bottom three is getting tough because it has become such a "popularity" contest. My bottom three were: Hollie, Colton, and Elise. I'm doubting that America will see it that way. I think Elise goes home - which is a shame, I enjoy her singing - but the judges did get their comments right on her she needs to cut loose like she did with the Zepplin song. Thought Phillip and Joshua did really well. Skylar continues to surprise me - she is probably the most improved and may be the best "performer." Thought the idea of a try at a "soul" song was good - but the performances didn't seem very good. Oh well. __________________ *John*

04-05-2012, 07:01 PM	#44
Brian5581 Add-on Aficionado Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: New Jersey Posts: 15,224	Got to get caught up this weekend. Didn't watch last week's results show yet, then will have last night's show and of course tonight's results. Based solely on who's remaining though, I'd have to say your prediction is likely correct, John.

04-05-2012, 08:29 PM	#47
Presley Grand Villa Join Date: Apr 2011 Posts: 1,018	I don't watch every week, but did watch last night. Joshua is always my favorite by a mile. I think Jessica's voice is incredible, but I don't see it as being unique compared to what is already in the mainstream. Skylar was great last night. When she was chosen for the final 24, I didn't see the attraction. Finally, last night, I could see what the judges apparently saw weeks ago. DeAndre - he wins the cute kid with the nice hair award. He is very talented, but I just can't stand the sound of the high range. I felt the same way about Fantasia years ago. I couldn't stand the sound of her voice, but did appreciate that she had talent.

04-19-2012, 02:09 PM	#50
minniekissedme Add-on Aficionado Join Date: May 2008 Location: In my car with three kids. Posts: 6,665	Don't two have to go tonight? Colton sure did himself no favors with his lame attempt at EWF. The audience was so underwhelmed and had no clue what he performed. If he goes, which I think could be possible, Phillip Phillips could come out the winner. I thought he was super last night. I'm getting perturbed with Joshua and his "screaming" every song. I'd like him to just sing a bit more... __________________ Are you MOD? aka MouseOwnersDad?? Click here to join! MKM Maulers 2012-13 Champion of the MODly Men of the World Fantasy Football League

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode